Should you hire a brilliant man or a mediocre guy instead?

Although the choice seems obvious at first, there is more to the subject then meets the eye. In an article published in February 1924 issue of The American Magazine the author tells his experience about hiring brilliant men. It is a very enjoyable read and I warmly suggest it.

What is wrong with brilliant man

"Brilliant" men often have very strong emotionally driven periods during which they either become over-creative or overly-depressed. This leads to a habit not to finish jobs they start as their creative impulse moves them to another, more interesting project or idea. Simply they have seen the project being born in their minds, all ideas and aspects of it carefully analyzed and an outcome already predicted. But when it comes to actually doing it, brilliant men are often bored and not interested. They are in constant hunger for intellectual challenges and are indeed lazy for practical purposes. That is bad for employers as they often have to pay too much for their services (brilliant men tend to have a high opinion of themselves).

Having a brilliant man in a team does not have to have negative consequences. Ideas they give can often drive the business into great new ventures. If you are to hire a brilliant person, make sure you have a team of people able to cope with extreme amount of fresh ideas. Interestingly only a "mediocre" guy can do this well. This makes mediocre guy, well... brilliant.

See also:


Posted in: Rants
TAGS:, , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
Leave a comment

One Comment

  1. Dr. Carl Edwin Lindgren
    Dec 27th, 2008

    To be honest, brilliant people have baggage. These "over-creative or overly-depressed" periods can be a sign of obsessive compulsive disorder and even worse bi-polar disorder. Many brilliant people create because they are obsessed by a small insignificant problem or point that would not cause a moments notice to Mr. Average. They may even stay awake for days and not eat while trying to do an specific mathematics problem. However, the same people once they solve the problem are easily prone to become depressed. While searching they are consumed and when they should be happy, they are usually sad. In many cases, the brilliant people can and do make life difficult for themselves and others.

    Carl

Have your say

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*

Subscribe without commenting

About Vladimir

vladimir prelovac Hi! My name is Vladimir Prelovac. I am a computer engineer by profession and an adventurer by state of mind.

"I would love to change the world, I just don't have the source code yet."

Books by Vladimir

WordPress Plugin Devleopment Book WordPress Plugin Development: Beginner's Guide

Published by Packt Publishing, available online through Amazon. Click the image for more information.

Consulting Services

Professional WordPress Services, including custom developed plugins and themes

Expert on-site WordPress SEO consulting and an 'out-of-the-box thinking' approach to problems